Introduction
Chief Editor’s Note
As many of you might be aware, the RECORDER team brought out a special print edition commemorating the 75th anniversary of the CSEG. In one section of this special edition, we asked professionals across the globe about their vision of geophysics for the next 25 years. Our past Chief Editor, Satinder Chopra, coordinated this compilation and made it happen. Due to some unforeseen constraints, we could print only summarized versions of those responses. However, we are now ready to publish the full unabridged commentaries on our online portal. In this edition, we are posting the third installment of our six-part series.
Cheers.
Nilanjan Ganguly
Where do you see geophysics in the next 25 years?
This question was shared with me by Nilanjan Ganguly, Chief Editor of RECORDER, who requested me to invite contributions for the RECORDER special issue commemorating the CSEG’s 75th anniversary this May. It’s truly a significant milestone for the CSEG, one that brings great pride to us as Canadian geophysicists.
I reached out to several prominent figures in our industry, asking them to share their vision for the future of geophysics. While 25 years is a long time to predict, current trends provide valuable insights for making educated forecasts. Given the open-ended nature of the question, some respondents initially expressed concerns about addressing it within the stipulated word limit of 500-1000 words. They were assured, however, that they could use their discretion and flexibility in crafting their responses.
I received responses from eighteen individuals, which have been included in this article. The order of the responses reflects the order in which I received them.
SHAWN MAXWELL
GEOPHYSICAL AND GEOMECHANICAL ADVISOR-CHIEF G&G, OVINTIV, HOUSTON, SHAWN.MAXWELL@OVINTIV.COM
My niche area of ‘unconventional’ geophysics is passive seismic or geomechanical monitoring. Looking back over the past 25 years we have seen microseismic monitoring and induced seismicity emerge from niche geophysical technologies to a prominent position within the industry and specifically CSEG. Not only is the technology impactful to image hydraulic fracture networks, but it has also grown in importance for hazard monitoring, particularly in tracking induced earthquakes. The technology significantly impacts petroleum engineers with oil and gas companies regularly adopting new commercial offerings.
Looking ahead to the next 25 years, complimentary technologies will continue to expand, including the monitoring of passive geomechanical strains. While passive (micro)seismicity focuses on one aspect of geomechanical deformation processes in reservoirs -specifically instantaneous shear failures associated with slip of pre-existing rock fabric -complimentary strain monitoring will offer additional insights. Techniques such as fiber optics, satellite interferometry, geodetic movements and extensometers will help provide a more complete understanding of rock deformation. Integrating these technologies with conventional geological mapping and geophysical imaging will lead to powerful, integrated geomechanical assessments that can be applied to a wide variety of engineering challenges.
This integrated information will assist engineers to optimize injections and hydraulic fracturing, investigating wellbore stability, and analyzing reservoir drainage and conformance. Geophysicists will be integral in supporting operational activities including oil and gas extraction, mining, civil engineering of underground excavations, geothermal and carbon storage. However, there are challenges to be overcome, particularly in optimizing monitoring systems and developing emerging processing and interpretational tools -the foundational elements of geophysics.
We have a unique opportunity to take a more active role in advocating these monitoring solutions and interpretational workflows to our engineering colleagues, enhancing the application of geophysics to address operational issues. The next generation of geoscientists will undoubtedly ‘shake things up’ with these ‘groundbreaking’ geophysical technologies.
BILL GOODWAY
SCIENTIFIC ADVISOR QUANTITATIVE INTERPRETATION AND AVO TECHNOLOGY, QEYE LABS, CALGARY, BG@QEYE-LABS.COM
Rather than trying to predict where geophysics will be in 25 years, I would like to focus on the developments and innovations in applied geophysics over this period. Within this scope, I will specifically delve into the design of land acquisition for 3D seismic data, as well as AVO and its quantitative interpretation.
- Land 3D acquisition design will move away from prohibitively inefficient and deficient orthogonal cross-spread design to improved 3D “stack array” sampling quality for sustainable cost-effective and environmentally friendly parallel design, e.g., Optiseis EcoSeis©.
Land 3D seismic data are almost universally acquired with orthogonal coarse crossline cross-spread geometry designs, which result in severe asymmetry between line and station dimensions.
The design criteria are to prioritize densely sampling the in-line receiver and shot stations at twice the fine bin dimension. However, this comes at the expense of significantly larger receiver and shot line spacings compared with station spacings, resulting in extremely erratic offset and azimuth sampling within and between bins.
This asymmetry introduces severe statistical and aliasing S/N limitations for key processing and inversion steps such as surface consistent statics, pre-stack migration (PSTM) and AVO/QI. These issues arise from the lack of near offsets and the discontinuous, erratic intra-bin offset sampling, as these applications have strict “stack array” (Anstey 1986) requirements for dense regularly sampled shot, receiver, and common reflection point domains.
One solution to this acquisition cost and environmental surface equipment footprint, especially in relation to PSTM-AVO sampling dilemma, is to acquire a wide-azimuth cost efficient and environmentally sustainable parallel geometry with coincident shots and receivers. This naturally reduces the line dimension to match the station spacing in the in-line direction, while allowing for a finer crossline spacing that may be regular or staggered or dithered.
A design variously known as MegaBin (Goodway and Ragan, 1996) and more recently EcoSeis© (Vermeulen et al., 2022) was developed to achieve continuous intra-bin PSTM-AVO sampling. This design has been tested through quantified oversampled 3D patch decimation experiments that clearly demonstrate the superior signal-to-noise PSTM imaging and AVO/QI fidelity of these parallel geometries compared with the standard industry orthogonal cross-spread.
Since its introduction, parallel geometries such as MegaBin have faced criticism, for good reason, as their regular, coarse crossline bin spacing leads to aliasing that violates the Nyquist wavenumber limit.
However, since the 2000’s, coarse crossline interpolation has gained wide acceptance, thanks to the research and implementation of pre-stack 5D Minimum Weighted Norm Interpolation (Liu and Sacchi, 2004; Trad 2009) that has allowed previously Nyquist-challenged processes such as PSTM- AVO/QI to succeed.
As a result of this continued development of parallel 3D geometry design, from its introduction of MegaBin in the 90’s to the recent implementation of EcoSeis©, the future of land 3D will move completely away from deficient environmentally unsustainable orthogonal cross-spread design. It will instead adopt effective cost efficient, and sustainable parallel geometries that have been quantifiably proven to have superior signal-to-noise PSTM imaging and AVO/QI fidelity over the traditional orthogonal cross-spread (Goodway et al., 2024; 2025).
2. AVO-QI will move away from deterministic methods towards routine Machine Learning (ML) assisted fully anisotropic probabilistic rock physics inversion applications combined with elastic Full waveform inversion (FWI).
In seismic-based Quantitative Interpretation (QI) methods for reservoir characterization, there is a need to improve accuracy, and resolution in estimates of key rock physics parameters. Subsurface information obtained from standard AVO inversion is often ambiguous, as different lithologies and fluid configurations can produce similar elastic responses. This ambiguity is an intrinsic characteristic of the ill-posed non-uniqueness of the inversion problem, that can be mitigated by integrating relevant and non-redundant information into the inversion process.
Standard QI techniques typically do not account for lithological deposition, bed thickness distributions, and petrophysical relationships such as lithofacies, effective porosity, and fluid fill within the reservoir. Furthermore, for reservoir characterization, effective decision-making in exploration and development risk analysis requires a comprehensive assessment of the uncertainties associated with predictions based on QI.
Bayesian inference provides a robust framework to address these issues by applying a general, and flexible probabilistic approach for rigorous uncertainty propagation. This allows for the seamless integration of prior knowledge from multiple domains, for example in the method known as Direct Probabilistic Inversion (Goodway, 2024).
This prior information is readily available from logs, core and geological studies, which provide models for specific ranges of elastic properties for target zone facies, average thicknesses, and their petrophysical variation. It also includes data on stratigraphic positions, and the buoyancy relationships between gas, oil, and brine. By defining a set of rules based on this information, the solution space is dramatically reduced, unlike in deterministic QI, where this prior information is difficult to integrate. Moreover, the correct propagation of uncertainties through the inversion is not possible in deterministic methods.
These additional prior constraints of thicknesses, ordering, etc. can also help resolve units that are below seismic resolution. Additionally, the challenges presented by reservoir sands encased in VTI shales often require the use of more complex approximations to model anisotropic AVO responses. This is crucial to avoid the misinterpretation of false hydrocarbon AVO signatures, caused by overlaying anisotropic shales.
As a result of these advantages, current QI methods are expected to be replaced by anisotropic probabilistic inversion techniques that address these challenges within a probabilistic framework, providing higher anisotropic vertical resolution than deterministic AVO inversions.
References
Anstey, N. A., 1986, Whatever happened to ground roll? The Leading Edge, 5(3), 40-45. https://doi.org/10.1190/1.1439239
Goodway, W., and B. Ragan, 1996, “Mega-Bin”: Toward a cost effective “near symmetric patch geometry” for improved S/N & resolution from regular acquisition sampling and co-operative image processing”, CSEG convention abstracts, 99-102.
Goodway W., R. Cova, E. Mutual, W. Pardasie, A. Jakobsen, and H. Hansen, 2024, Direct probabilistic inversion: Adding back geology into geophysics through probabilistic inversion extended to accommodate anisotropy in quantitative interpretation; GeoConvention abstracts, 1-4.
Goodway, W., R. Cova, W. Pardasie, A. Crook, M. Naghizadeh, C. Crook, M. Hons, and M. Rodriguez, 2024, Land 3D acquisition design: Theory of wavefield sampling. Part 1: Past 3D design testing and assessment of cross-spread and parallel geometries, 42(9), 59-70. https://doi.org/10.3997/1365-2397.fb2024076
Goodway, W., A. Crook, R. Cova, M. Naghizadeh, M. Hons, M. Rodriguez, C. Crook and W. Pardasie, 2025, Land 3D acquisition design: Theory of wavefield sampling. Part 2: Present 3D design tests for environmentally sustainable sparse perturbed parallel geometries, First Break, 43(1), 89-100. https://doi.org/10.3997/1365-2397.fb2025009
Liu, B. and Sacchi, M. D., 2004, Minimum weighted norm interpolation of seismic records, Geophysics, 69(6), 1560-1568. https://doi.org/10.1190/1.1836829
Trad, D., 2009, Five-dimensional interpolation. Recovering from acquisition constraints, Geophysics, 74(6), V123-V132. https://doi.org/10.1190/1.3245216
Vermeulen P., A. Crook, M. Naghizadeh, and S. Ross, 2022, Turn your seismic program into a lean, green, resolution machine, GeoConvention conference abstracts,1-4.
![]()
Leave A Comment